MAIB lead investigator David Robertson's advice to superyacht owners after the 56m Bayesian sinking

4 images

Credit: Perini Navi

Exclusive interview: What does MAIB lead investigator David Robertson advise superyacht owners after the 56m Bayesian sinking?

20 November 2026 • Written by Lucy Williamson

Following yesterday’s publication of the MAIB’s final report on the sinking of Bayesian, BOAT speaks to lead investigator David Robertson about the lessons for superyacht owners, operators and crew – and the steps they can take to better understand their vessels and prepare for severe weather.

Superyacht owners, captains and managers should understand how their vessels behave in severe weather, including when anchored with sails stowed, according to David Robertson, Inspector of Marine Accidents at the UK’s Marine Accident Investigation Branch (MAIB) and lead investigator into the sinking of the 56-metre Perini Navi sailing yacht Bayesian.

Speaking exclusively to BOAT following publication of the MAIB’s final investigation report, Robertson urged owners to look beyond general guidance and consider the specific stability characteristics and operational risks of their own yachts.

"If you are a private yacht owner, operator or crew member, don't just go off social media commentary," he said. "Read the report yourself. Find out what it says, and think about how it applies to you. Work out: am I similarly vulnerable? If so, what can I do to mitigate that risk?"

He recommended seeking specialist advice where necessary. "If you want someone to do that for you, get a naval architect or your management company to think it through and establish exactly how your specific yacht is positioned."

David Robertson
Credit: MAIB

Understand your yacht's behaviour in different conditions

One of the central issues highlighted by the investigation was the need to understand how large sailing yachts behave when their sails are stowed, including when they are at anchor. Robertson believes owners should not assume that conventional operating practices or compliance with existing standards provide a complete picture of a vessel's vulnerabilities.

“The Large Yacht Code is seen internationally as a very high standard, but what we have seen in this accident is that it didn't manage to cope with understanding that large yachts are still significantly affected by wind when they have no sails set,” he said.

“All traditional guidance says ‘take sails down’. So now what? You can't take sails down that aren't there. If [the code] now adopts and understands how vessels are affected with no sails up, that would be really powerful. It would protect an awful lot more people.”

For owners, that means looking beyond generic guidance and establishing how their particular yacht is affected by wind in different operating conditions. Robertson suggests involving a naval architect or management company to review the vessel's characteristics and identify any risks that may not be apparent from its approved documentation.

He also cautions against assuming that a yacht's response can be judged by reference to another vessel, even if the two appear similar.

“Lots of people have asked me, why didn't the yacht near them have the same accident? Well, it's a different boat in different conditions. Every vessel is unique.”

A 3D scan of Bayesian following her salvage
Credit: MAIB

Prioritise preventing a knockdown

The findings also raise questions about the extent to which yachts can be made safer once they have been knocked onto their side. Robertson argues that the priority should be understanding and mitigating the risk of a vessel capsizing in the first place, rather than relying on changes to internal arrangements to protect those on board after the event.

“If you've got a yacht sitting upright and the wind starts increasing, going from there to flat in 15 seconds means lots of structural tweaks would make absolutely no difference once you're on your side,” he said. “Once a vessel goes over, if you have downflooding points in the hull, water will enter irrespective of what you do with interior doors. The logical, rational priority is stopping the boat from falling over in the first place.”

That puts the emphasis on vessel-specific risk assessments, an understanding of stability and windage, and clear operational guidance for masters and crew. It is not enough to assume that a yacht's design or regulatory certification automatically accounts for every possible combination of weather and operating conditions.

Review emergency procedures and equipment

Robertson's advice extends beyond the yacht's technical characteristics to the people and equipment on board. Crew members need to understand how to respond when an incident develops rapidly, while owners and operators should be confident that emergency procedures have been practised and that essential equipment can be accessed when it is needed.

“The actions of the Bayesian crew in getting people out meant that everyone who got out successfully stayed alive,” he said. “Do your people know that as well? Have you exercised that? How confident are you that they are competent? Do you know what to do in this kind of event as well? Do you know where your life jacket is? Are they in a reasonable position? Do you have someone on the upper deck?”

He also highlighted the importance of life-raft arrangements, including whether they would remain accessible and able to float free if a vessel were to capsize.

The yacht was lifted from the seabed on 21 June 2025
Credit: Alessandro Fucarini/AFP via Getty Images

“In this accident, the life raft was fundamental to survival. Those 15 people survived to a large extent because somebody manually got a life raft launched. In a 15-second knockdown, nobody has time to don lifejackets from lower cabins. If knockdown is a risk when sails are down, then life rafts must be guaranteed to surface even when the vessel is lying flat on her side. But every boat is different. It's not an easy job. Codes take a long time to generate properly.”

For Robertson, the broader lesson is that safety cannot be approached as a matter of simply meeting minimum standards. Owners, operators and crew need to understand the particular characteristics of their vessel, consider how it may respond in challenging conditions and ensure that the people on board are prepared.

The MAIB's report is intended to help the industry address those risks, with recommendations covering yacht design standards, crew training and weather information. Robertson's appeal is for those responsible for yachts to engage with its findings and consider what action is needed on their own vessels.

Robertson's quickfire checklist every owner should review:

  1. Evaluate bare-mast heel vulnerability: Request a formal windage and stability review from your naval architect to determine your yacht’s limiting gust speeds and downflooding angles when anchored with all sails stowed and centreboards raised.
  2. Audit life raft float-free geometry: Inspect where life rafts are stowed on deck. Verify whether a 90-degree list would trap raft containers under flybridge overhangs, main hoops, or guardrails as the hull submerges.
  3. Position upper-deck emergency lifejackets: Recognise that in a rapid knockdown event, guests and crew cannot reach lower-deck cabins to retrieve lifejackets. Ensure weather-protected emergency lifejacket lockers are maintained on the bridge deck or main saloon entry points.
  4. Drill for rapid-onset contingencies: Review crew training logs to ensure drills cover manual life raft launching, emergency pyrotechnics, and immediate passenger muster under extreme list conditions.
  5. Commission a bespoke risk assessment: Avoid relying on generic regulatory compliance certificates. Require your master and management company to establish clear, vessel-specific operational guidelines for securing hull openings during severe convective weather alerts at anchor.

Read More/MAIB publishes full accident report two years on from 56m yacht Bayesian sinking

Sponsored listings